Does Yesterday Count
as a Day?
What did I know, what did I know of love's austere and lonely offices?
Robert Hayden
"I'm putting my heart and soul into this," said Austin. "In
fact, I'm putting in a whole truckload of guts." We were in a sixth
grade writers' lab and Austin had chosen to respond to a prompt titled:
How to write a love letter. Kids focused on elements such as coming up
with an appropriate salutation (the preference was for ridiculously extravagant
terms of endearment) and even pen choices (a purple glitter gel pen was
recommended, and every i would be dotted with a heart.) Austin intuitively
recognized that a large part of it was about getting in the mood, and
although he had no particular recipient in mind and not much in the way
of content, he certainly approached it with the proper degree of passion.
His enthusiasm was a bracing tonic for my wilting spirit. After teaching
middle school kids for ten years, nothing they say surprises me much,
but I often find unexpected wisdom and delight in their comments. Well,
maybe I'm particularly attuned to this because I am actively - - one might
even say desperately -- searching for wisdom and delight. It's a strange
time, after all. The news depresses me and sleep has become a series of
fitful naps. Everyone is working too hard. Several friends are fighting
cancer. And autumn always makes me sad.
Especially today. This morning as my bedroom filled up with fall's soft
light, I remembered the phone call that woke me twenty-five years ago
with the news of my father's death. It was October 12, 1978, and I slept
then in the upstairs space of an old house in Syracuse, New York where
I was attending graduate school. The leaves of the maple outside my window
were outrageously yellow. Autumns were shameless in that time and place,
bleeding bright color into everything, a veritable banquet of decay, but
I knew nothing of loss until that very instant. My father was abruptly
and inexplicably dead, and twenty-five years have not erased the capacity
of this fact to stun me.
I suppose it is the self-indulgent compulsion of writers to try to articulate
everything they have experienced or imagined, hoping perhaps to discover
in the process what it means. So I wondered this morning how twenty-five
years can happen so suddenly, and why I am always ten steps behind, still
scratching my head and searching my heart and trying to figure things
out after everyone else has left the stage. Does anyone understand what's
happening while it's happening? Why is there such a delay between event
and meaning? Is it our nature to perceive the full depth of love only
when it is too late to act upon it? But let's not dwell on this today,
for I am already tediously intimate with sadness and drink too often of
the poison of regret. Instead, what I wanted to rally on this anniversary
morning were the understandings I had gleaned over twenty-five years --
a progress report, an optimist's transcription.
There were many ways to begin. But for some reason I snagged a sudden
memory of my father assembling tall fruit baskets as gifts to customers
and friends. I hadn't thought about it for years. He would select the
roundest oranges, the most exquisite grapes, an arc of firm bananas, and
arrange them artfully in woven baskets, covering them all with stiff yellow
cellophane twisted and ribboned at the top. My mother told him he was
a show-off and a fool wasting time and money on something that no one
would appreciate and for which there would be no return, but the small
pleasure of creating and giving was perhaps his gift to himself -- its
own sufficient satisfaction. I used to think the taunting commentary had
ruined it, but now I see it would not have been so easily taken from him.
And I find myself on this October morning decades later holding in my
heart two gifts that have not expired: a graceful example of giving, and
a lavish image of beauty -- fruit in basket, a still-life spilling over.
I was a watchful, well-intentioned child and I, too, wanted to do something
beautiful. I tried to draw, having observed my father for many years painting
murals, boughs of tender heart-shaped leaves, peacocks, clowns, and exotic
flowers, even on the ceiling. I remember the smell of the casein paints,
oily sweet dollops from silver tubes in colors like burnt umber, crimson,
and cerulean. Alas, nothing would come from my brush but amorphous curly
curves, and my pencil yielded only trivial doodles that never seemed to
evolve.
I tried to write, striving for the ornate incongruous eloquence my father
had forged from his bilingual background, from the hard streets and sad
stories, from an innate sense of poetry that no one could have taught
him. My best composition was a note on loose-leaf paper that I left for
him on the kitchen table in which I wished him good morning and told him
I loved him, with a penciled daisy by my name. He turned the note over
and responded in kind on the back. Many things happened in the rush of
time that followed, some of them hurtful and terrible, but I remain at
the core of me the same earnest girl, and I know with certainty that these
words we exchanged are still current.
So maybe it is no coincidence that I now teach about letters and love
and respond with ridiculous sentiment to declarations of passion and curiosity,
especially from children. Which brings me to my all-time favorite middle
school question: Does yesterday count as a day? This came from Arthur,
and I know what he meant: it was a three-day camping trip, and he wondered
if the days we spent traveling were included. However, I heard the question
in its grander context, and like all adults who were present, I instantly
imagined having the capacity to selectively keep or delete each day of
my life, simply whiting out the bad ones, getting a second chance at everything.
We laughed. But I pondered the question for a long time.
And I never could come up with a yes or no answer, for that would be
a linear response to a circular mystery. All I have are further questions.
What is the sum total of a life? Do the events of its conclusion necessarily
supersede the thousands that preceded them? Can we pick and choose from
the inventory that is left to us? Can we transform some of the pain into
compassion? Replace constrictive reason with defiant hope? What, in the
end, really counts?
It is twenty-five years since my father's death. I am sure love has no
expiration date. I believe that parts of yesterday count, but only as
I choose to see them now. And I think it takes a truckload of guts to
live a life.
Cynthia Carbone Ward

|